Scoring cards for this theme…

← Gollum, Riddle Master

Nightmares Under the Mountain

stretch

Gollum leads a den of Horrors and Halflings, and something ancient stirs in the dark below.

Horror×1ETB value×0.5

Sets your commander and theme, then adds about 25 cards that fit plus 20 lands. You fill in the rest.

High Impact Cards

The top 40 of 117 cards that fit

Back to Top Picks

Sort by

Card Type

Colors

Top pickHidden gemBoth40 of 40 cards

HorrorETB value
score
0.94
fit
0.70
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.85
pop
1.43
art
1.10
#1,132$0.41Daarken
HorrorETB value
score
0.85
fit
0.65
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.65
pop
2.09
art
1.10
#15,784$0.07Carl Critchlow
HorrorETB value
score
0.80
fit
0.65
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.70
pop
1.62
art
1.20
#2,202$19.64Babs Webb
Horror
score
0.76
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.75
pop
1.95
art
1.10
#5,785$0.47Anato Finnstark
HorrorETB value
score
0.68
fit
0.65
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.60
pop
1.87
art
1.10
#17,060$0.18Daren Bader
HorrorETB value
score
0.65
fit
0.57
cmdr
1.10
qual
0.72
pop
1.54
art
1.10
#1,682$0.28John Thacker
HorrorETB value
score
0.51
fit
0.65
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.55
pop
1.61
art
1.10
#13,597$0.21Izzy
Horror
score
0.50
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.60
pop
1.80
art
1.10
#13,132$0.20Fang Xinyu
HorrorETB value
score
0.49
fit
0.65
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.55
pop
1.56
art
1.10
#9,991$0.41Mathias Kollros
HorrorETB value
score
0.47
fit
0.63
cmdr
1.12
qual
0.55
pop
1.51
art
1.10
#7,459$0.30Jorge Gutierrez Garcia
Horror
score
0.45
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.25
qual
0.55
pop
1.62
art
1.10
#14,714$0.23Simon Dominic
Horror
score
0.42
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.11
qual
0.60
pop
1.41
art
1.15
#2,226$9.83Joshua Raphael
Horror
score
0.42
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.60
pop
1.38
art
1.20
#1,877$10.01Todd Lockwood
Horror
score
0.41
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.26
qual
0.60
pop
1.28
art
1.10
#1,077$1.11Chase Stone
HorrorETB value
score
0.40
fit
0.65
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.50
pop
1.47
art
1.10
#18,693$0.12Mark A. Nelson
HorrorETB value
score
0.40
fit
0.63
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.50
pop
1.52
art
1.10
#28,027$0.14Nils Hamm
HorrorETB value
score
0.39
fit
0.63
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.50
pop
1.48
art
1.10
#20,518$0.16Randy Vargas
HorrorETB value
score
0.39
fit
0.60
cmdr
1.11
qual
0.50
pop
1.38
art
1.20
#9,102$0.22Alexander Ostrowski
Horror
score
0.38
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.60
pop
1.38
art
1.10
#1,874$7.23Thomas M. Baxa
Horror
score
0.38
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.55
pop
1.55
art
1.10
#9,530$0.52Sandra Everingham
HorrorETB value
score
0.37
fit
0.60
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.50
pop
1.46
art
1.10
#18,162$0.12Lordigan
HorrorETB value
score
0.37
fit
0.63
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.50
pop
1.40
art
1.10
#10,683$0.27Mike Franchina
HorrorETB value
score
0.36
fit
0.63
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.50
pop
1.37
art
1.10
#8,471$0.01Mark Tedin
HorrorETB value
score
0.36
fit
0.63
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.50
pop
1.37
art
1.10
#7,940$0.49Nils Hamm
HorrorETB value
score
0.36
fit
0.63
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.50
pop
1.36
art
1.10
#7,539$0.38Brian Valeza
Horror
score
0.35
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.25
qual
0.50
pop
1.44
art
1.10
#14,315$0.11David Astruga
HorrorETB value
score
0.33
fit
0.57
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.50
pop
1.49
art
1.00
#23,061$0.32
Horror
score
0.32
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.11
qual
0.60
pop
1.13
art
1.10
#436$0.71Stephan Martiniere
Horror
score
0.32
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.10
qual
0.50
pop
1.48
art
1.10
#21,511$0.22Helge C. Balzer
HorrorETB value
score
0.31
fit
0.60
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.45
pop
1.33
art
1.20
UnrankedJason Felix
Horror
score
0.31
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.50
pop
1.48
art
1.10
#20,178$0.18Maxime Minard
Horror
score
0.31
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.50
pop
1.40
art
1.15
#11,012$0.28Mark Tedin
Horror
score
0.31
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.50
pop
1.45
art
1.10
#16,599$0.28Brian Valeza
Horror
score
0.31
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.50
pop
1.45
art
1.10
#15,962$0.20Piotr Foksowicz
HorrorETB value
score
0.30
fit
0.63
cmdr
1.10
qual
0.45
pop
1.31
art
1.10
#23,136$0.21Milivoj Ćeran
HorrorETB value
score
0.30
fit
0.65
cmdr
1.11
qual
0.45
pop
1.24
art
1.10
#8,989$0.26Dan Watson
Horror
score
0.29
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.50
pop
1.38
art
1.10
#9,126$0.24Jeff Laubenstein
HorrorETB value
score
0.29
fit
0.63
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.45
pop
1.29
art
1.10
#19,166$0.20David Auden Nash
Horror
score
0.29
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.10
qual
0.50
pop
1.35
art
1.10
#6,625$0.22Esuthio
Horror
score
0.29
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.11
qual
0.50
pop
1.48
art
1.00
#20,331$0.38Jesper Ejsing

Show scoring details