Scoring cards for this theme…

← Gollum, Riddle Master

Thief! Baggins!

stretch

Snatch what belongs to your opponents, casting their cards for yourself while Gollum's riddles keep everyone busy.

Theft×1Cast from exile×0.6Card draw×0.3

Sets your commander and theme, then adds about 25 cards that fit plus 20 lands. You fill in the rest.

High Impact Cards

The top 40 of 164 cards that fit

Back to Top Picks

Sort by

Card Type

Colors

Top pickHidden gemBoth40 of 40 cards

TheftCast from exile
score
1.30
fit
1.01
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.70
pop
2.21
art
1.00
#10,933$0.32David Rapoza
Theft
score
0.98
fit
0.80
cmdr
1.07
qual
0.78
pop
1.52
art
1.10
#1,572$17.55Yongjae Choi
Theft
score
0.94
fit
0.90
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.65
pop
1.99
art
1.00
#11,757$7.74
TheftCast from exileCard draw
score
0.78
fit
1.07
cmdr
1.11
qual
0.60
pop
1.41
art
1.00
#2,226$9.83Brent Hollowell
TheftCast from exile
score
0.75
fit
1.01
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.60
pop
1.45
art
1.10
#2,636$1.16Rudy Siswanto
TheftCast from exile
score
0.75
fit
0.95
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.65
pop
1.50
art
1.00
#2,077$0.26Daarken
TheftCast from exileCard draw
score
0.74
fit
0.87
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.65
pop
1.62
art
1.00
#3,398$5.62
TheftCast from exileCard draw
score
0.60
fit
0.64
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.70
pop
1.59
art
1.00
#1,999$0.70
Theft
score
0.59
fit
0.80
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.70
pop
1.25
art
1.00
#582$20.54
TheftCard draw
score
0.59
fit
0.66
cmdr
1.08
qual
0.60
pop
1.61
art
1.10
#5,807$0.52Warren Mahy
Theft
score
0.58
fit
0.70
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.65
pop
1.58
art
1.00
#2,850$2.57Yongjae Choi
Theft
score
0.57
fit
0.80
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.55
pop
1.74
art
1.00
#27,988$0.49Christopher Rush
TheftCast from exileCard draw
score
0.55
fit
0.90
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.55
pop
1.51
art
1.00
#7,396$0.37
Theft
score
0.55
fit
0.70
cmdr
1.07
qual
0.60
pop
1.57
art
1.00
#4,785$4.05Lucas Graciano
Theft
score
0.54
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.65
pop
2.07
art
1.00
#14,592$0.11Karl Kopinski
Theft
score
0.54
fit
0.40
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.85
pop
1.73
art
1.00
#3,058$2.26Tiffany Turrill
TheftCast from exile
score
0.54
fit
0.65
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.80
pop
1.16
art
1.00
#392$4.22
Theft
score
0.54
fit
0.70
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.55
pop
1.70
art
1.10
#22,735$2.60Wayne Wu
Theft
score
0.53
fit
0.60
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.65
pop
1.60
art
1.05
#3,105$1.53Irina Nordsol
Theft
score
0.53
fit
0.90
cmdr
1.03
qual
0.50
pop
1.46
art
1.10
#17,376$0.13Zoltan Boros & Gabor Szikszai
TheftCast from exileCard draw
score
0.52
fit
0.95
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.55
pop
1.34
art
1.00
#2,644$2.28
Theft
score
0.51
fit
0.70
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.60
pop
1.44
art
1.10
#2,490$1.85Eric Deschamps
TheftCast from exileCard draw
score
0.50
fit
0.97
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.50
pop
1.45
art
1.00
#16,891$0.27
Theft
score
0.50
fit
0.40
cmdr
1.05
qual
0.82
pop
1.59
art
1.00
#2,001$6.20Piotr Dura
TheftCast from exile
score
0.50
fit
0.75
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.60
pop
1.42
art
1.00
#2,314$23.75
TheftCast from exileCard draw
score
0.50
fit
0.91
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.55
pop
1.33
art
1.00
#2,468$0.82
Theft
score
0.48
fit
0.50
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.72
pop
1.59
art
1.00
#1,980$0.34
TheftCast from exileCard draw
score
0.47
fit
0.79
cmdr
1.13
qual
0.50
pop
1.36
art
1.10
#7,268$0.33Caroline Gariba
Theft
score
0.47
fit
0.60
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.60
pop
1.69
art
1.00
#8,231$0.34Whit Brachna
Theft
score
0.47
fit
0.60
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.60
pop
1.69
art
1.00
#8,197$0.39
Theft
score
0.47
fit
0.70
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.60
pop
1.44
art
1.00
#2,588$0.28
TheftCast from exile
score
0.46
fit
0.88
cmdr
1.09
qual
0.50
pop
1.36
art
1.00
#7,539$0.38Brian Valeza
Theft
score
0.45
fit
0.40
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.68
pop
2.01
art
1.00
#8,455$0.91Ben Wootten
TheftCast from exile
score
0.44
fit
0.81
cmdr
1.07
qual
0.55
pop
1.24
art
1.00
#1,302$17.11
TheftCast from exileCard draw
score
0.43
fit
0.79
cmdr
1.08
qual
0.50
pop
1.43
art
1.00
#14,132$1.51
TheftCast from exile
score
0.43
fit
0.82
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.55
pop
1.28
art
1.00
#1,699$10.47
Theft
score
0.42
fit
0.80
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.55
pop
1.29
art
1.00
#1,843$25.71
TheftCast from exile
score
0.42
fit
0.88
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.50
pop
1.35
art
1.00
#6,731$0.40
Theft
score
0.41
fit
0.80
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.55
pop
1.27
art
1.00
#1,553$11.42Tomasz Jedruszek
Card drawCast from exile
score
0.40
fit
0.27
cmdr
1.00
qual
0.85
pop
1.93
art
1.00
#5,497$4.44

Show scoring details